Skip to content

Schütte MADURA shower column WITH thermostat, 38 °C detent vs HOMELODY shower column with thermostat, 22 × 22 cm head, rail 855–1105 mm

A warranty and a phone number, or a rail that still moves?

These are the two columns in this catalogue that arrive with their thermostatic mixer, which is what separates them from the cheaper columns that state "no mixer" in their first line. Between the two, one publishes almost nothing and backs it with a warranty; the other publishes a rail range and a head size.

Schütte MADURA chrome shower column with a thermostatic mixer

Schütte MADURA shower column WITH thermostat, 38 °C detent

Wins 2 of 8

Check price

≈ £144 / 111 €

HOMELODY chrome shower column with a thermostatic mixer and square rain head

HOMELODY shower column with thermostat, 22 × 22 cm head, rail 855–1105 mm

Wins 4 of 8

Check price

≈ 140 €

Line by line

Compared on MADURA shower column WITH thermostat, 38 °C detent shower column with thermostat, 22 × 22 cm head, rail 855–1105 mm
Thermostatic mixer included Yes — stated Yes — stated
Rail height range Not stated as a figure 855 to 1105 mm
Adjustable after fitting Not stated Yes — stated to adjust with the brackets already fixed
Head size Not stated by the maker 22 × 22 cm, published also as 9 inch
Head material Not stated by the maker Chrome-plated ABS
Mixer body material Not stated by the maker Brass — stated
Temperature detent 38 °C Stated as a thermostat with scald protection
Manufacturer warranty Five years — stated Not stated as a term

A tick marks the better answer on that line only. Counting ticks does not decide the page — the two verdicts below do, because these products answer different questions.

Which one, for whom

Buy the Schütte MADURA shower column WITH thermostat, 38 °C detent

Take the Schütte if you want a German manufacturer with a service telephone number, a stated five-year warranty and a detent described as a detent. It publishes almost no dimensions, which on a column that has to span two holes in a tiled wall is a real gap.

Buy the HOMELODY shower column with thermostat, 22 × 22 cm head, rail 855–1105 mm

Take the HOMELODY if the wall is already drilled and the head height still has to be got right — it is the only column here stated to adjust between 855 and 1105 mm after the brackets are on. Read its scald-protection wording as the maker's: a thermostat holds a temperature, it does not guarantee safety.

Questions people actually ask

Is a column with a thermostat worth the extra?

Compare it against a cheaper column plus a separate thermostat, which is what the alternative actually costs. On that arithmetic, both of these stop looking expensive — and a thermostat holds temperature when someone flushes a toilet, which is the whole reason to have one.

What does "adjustable after installation" change?

Everything, the day after fitting. Most columns are set once, and on tile a hole in the wrong place is permanent. One of these two states that the rail still slides between 855 and 1105 mm with the brackets fixed.

The full reviews